h1

Tell, don’t show

January 4, 2013

This week, I am revising a short story that will be published in February. One of the things I do while revising the first draft of a story is to identify the passages where I’m telling and to replace them with showing.

But I also stumbled across a few “telling” passages that I didn’t change.

While “show, don’t tell” is most often good advice, showing isn’t always better than telling.

Just a quick reminder: Showing is describing things in vivid details that allow readers to come to their own conclusions. Telling is giving the reader summaries and interpretations.

So when you’re showing, everything happens in real time. Events take up more space on the page if you show them instead of telling. If you describe something at length, readers will automatically think that the event or action holds a certain importance. So if you have unimportant, everyday tasks in your story, it might be better to tell.

Here are two examples from my short story.

The woman behind the front desk took one look at their sodden clothes and quickly checked them in.

It’s Valentine’s Day, and my main character, Annie, has booked a room at a cozy little inn to seduce her girlfriend. If I wrote half a page of dialogue about the inn’s manager welcoming them, handing over the key, and letting them know at what time they can have breakfast, it would take the focus from what’s really important in this scene. So instead of showing all the details of their interaction with the manager, I summarized and just said that the manager checked them in.

The second example is similar:

They ordered, and within ten minutes the waiter returned with the fries and two Caesar salads.

Here, Drew and Annie are enjoying a romantic dinner, but I want the focus to be on their interaction, the emotions, not on their interaction with the waiter, so instead of showing the ordering process, I summed it up and jumped ahead in time.

So maybe instead of advising writers to “show, don’t tell,” we should advise them to “show and tell.” The trick is to figure out when it’s better to show (probably 90% of the time) and when it’s better to tell.

Here are links to some of my previous posts about showing and telling:

The golden rule

Show, don’t tell

Showing emotions

Advertisements

8 comments

  1. I ‘finally’ get it. Before your Blog, I was always going ‘huh’ when someone was saying show dont tell. Thanks for making it so simple even I could understand it Jae.


  2. I agree – showing is most effective, but there is a time for telling


  3. Thank you, Gwen and Devlyn. I’m very glad you found the blog post helpful.


  4. This is really great advice! Glad to have found your blog! 🙂 Beth


    • Glad you enjoyed the post.


  5. Thanks for the tips. i have just started my first YA, which is a far cry from the picture books I normally write, and where there’s rarely room to tell.

    Found your blog because I have just finished and loved your novel, Something in the Wine.


    • Hello, Joanna. Thanks for your comment. I hope you find the tips on my blog helpful. Also, thanks for letting me know you liked my newest novel.


  6. I detest and boycott all fiction wriutten in the spirit of “show, don’t tell”; consequently, there is no way you can trick me into telling shamelessly instead of showing, and you will not be able to trick me into considering “show, don’t tell” a good advice instead of a corrupt and fascist commandment.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: